Publicatie
Publication date
Shifts in patients’ question-asking behaviour between 2007 and 2016: an observational study of video recorded general practice consultations’.
Meijers, M., Potappel, A., Kloek, C., olde Hartman, T., Spreeuwenberg, P., Dulmen, S. van, Noordman, J. Shifts in patients’ question-asking behaviour between 2007 and 2016: an observational study of video recorded general practice consultations’. Patient Education and Counseling: 2020, 103(6), p. 1168-1175.
Download the PDF
Objective
To gain insight into patient participation in general practice by examining if and how patients’ question-asking behaviour has changed over the years (2007–2016).
Methods
A random set of real-life video-recorded consultations collected in 2015–2016 (n = 437) was observed and compared with that of a former study in 2007–2008 (n = 533). Patients’ question-asking behaviour was coded using an adapted RIAS protocol containing six categories: medical condition/therapeutic regimen; psychosocial; social context; lifestyle; ask for opinion doctor; practical. GPs and patients completed questionnaires about their background characteristics. Data were analysed using multi-level analysis.
Results
Patients asked fewer questions in 2016 than in 2007. The type of question-asking behaviour changed significantly: in particular medical questions decreased while practical questions increased. Less educated patients asked significantly more practical questions than higher educated patients.
Conclusion
Contrary to our expectations, patients’ question-asking has decreased in 2016 compared to 2007, while the average consultation length has increased. The type of questions shifted from medical to practical, especially in less educated patients. It seems that GPs’ professional role has expanded over time, since patients nowadays ask their GP more non-medical questions.
Practice implications
GPs probably could continue facilitating patient involvement by more frequently using partnership-building and supportive communication.
To gain insight into patient participation in general practice by examining if and how patients’ question-asking behaviour has changed over the years (2007–2016).
Methods
A random set of real-life video-recorded consultations collected in 2015–2016 (n = 437) was observed and compared with that of a former study in 2007–2008 (n = 533). Patients’ question-asking behaviour was coded using an adapted RIAS protocol containing six categories: medical condition/therapeutic regimen; psychosocial; social context; lifestyle; ask for opinion doctor; practical. GPs and patients completed questionnaires about their background characteristics. Data were analysed using multi-level analysis.
Results
Patients asked fewer questions in 2016 than in 2007. The type of question-asking behaviour changed significantly: in particular medical questions decreased while practical questions increased. Less educated patients asked significantly more practical questions than higher educated patients.
Conclusion
Contrary to our expectations, patients’ question-asking has decreased in 2016 compared to 2007, while the average consultation length has increased. The type of questions shifted from medical to practical, especially in less educated patients. It seems that GPs’ professional role has expanded over time, since patients nowadays ask their GP more non-medical questions.
Practice implications
GPs probably could continue facilitating patient involvement by more frequently using partnership-building and supportive communication.
Objective
To gain insight into patient participation in general practice by examining if and how patients’ question-asking behaviour has changed over the years (2007–2016).
Methods
A random set of real-life video-recorded consultations collected in 2015–2016 (n = 437) was observed and compared with that of a former study in 2007–2008 (n = 533). Patients’ question-asking behaviour was coded using an adapted RIAS protocol containing six categories: medical condition/therapeutic regimen; psychosocial; social context; lifestyle; ask for opinion doctor; practical. GPs and patients completed questionnaires about their background characteristics. Data were analysed using multi-level analysis.
Results
Patients asked fewer questions in 2016 than in 2007. The type of question-asking behaviour changed significantly: in particular medical questions decreased while practical questions increased. Less educated patients asked significantly more practical questions than higher educated patients.
Conclusion
Contrary to our expectations, patients’ question-asking has decreased in 2016 compared to 2007, while the average consultation length has increased. The type of questions shifted from medical to practical, especially in less educated patients. It seems that GPs’ professional role has expanded over time, since patients nowadays ask their GP more non-medical questions.
Practice implications
GPs probably could continue facilitating patient involvement by more frequently using partnership-building and supportive communication.
To gain insight into patient participation in general practice by examining if and how patients’ question-asking behaviour has changed over the years (2007–2016).
Methods
A random set of real-life video-recorded consultations collected in 2015–2016 (n = 437) was observed and compared with that of a former study in 2007–2008 (n = 533). Patients’ question-asking behaviour was coded using an adapted RIAS protocol containing six categories: medical condition/therapeutic regimen; psychosocial; social context; lifestyle; ask for opinion doctor; practical. GPs and patients completed questionnaires about their background characteristics. Data were analysed using multi-level analysis.
Results
Patients asked fewer questions in 2016 than in 2007. The type of question-asking behaviour changed significantly: in particular medical questions decreased while practical questions increased. Less educated patients asked significantly more practical questions than higher educated patients.
Conclusion
Contrary to our expectations, patients’ question-asking has decreased in 2016 compared to 2007, while the average consultation length has increased. The type of questions shifted from medical to practical, especially in less educated patients. It seems that GPs’ professional role has expanded over time, since patients nowadays ask their GP more non-medical questions.
Practice implications
GPs probably could continue facilitating patient involvement by more frequently using partnership-building and supportive communication.